Friday, December 13, 2013

To Sue or not to Sue...That is the Question



The words “I have Chronic Beryllium Disease” tumbled around in my brain, even before getting the final diagnosis.  Internet searches came up with not so pleasant reports of scarring over of lung tissues and eventual death.  Physical death is inevitable for everyone, but I’d prefer it not be from a progressive disease begotten from the job I had when I was seventeen.  The doctor assured me that it is not a death sentence and that if we see progression, there are effective treatments available. 

As I shared with friends and family members, the questions, “Did you talk to a lawyer?”, or “Can you sue the former employer?” always came up.  Of course, I researched the idea, but in the end I decided not to for several reasons.  Many friends and family have said that I’m sort of a life philosopher, so here is my philosophy on the subject.

The question I had to ask myself, first was How angry am I about this? Typically when you perceive that you have been wronged, the first impulse may be to get an attorney and to try to fix the wrong…How angry was I and what would it accomplish and how long would it take?  Then, if I chose to sue, as I went through the long process, how much more upset would it make me and would it gnaw away my insides.  

That’s when I gave thought to how much of my personal life had I lost up to this point and how much would a long drawn out lawsuit take up of my present personal life, my emotional life, my financial life and my physical health going forward.  I never lost a dime of income from Chronic Beryllium Disease and my personal life was not impacted.  I had a long business career and am now retired

Besides, the beryllium plant I worked in didn’t keep it a secret that the element was hazardous.  I think back to the days to when we showered at the end of the workday.  We would joke and chuckle about washing off all of the beryllium so that we didn’t get Berylliosis (new name Chronic Beryllium Disease CBD).  I guess we laughed not because we didn’t take it seriously, but just because the odds of getting it seemed so great. 
I remembered the times when I was a lab technician and I carried around hot beryllium tubes in what were likely asbestos gloves.  The thought never crossed my mind that I could get any kind of disease despite the warnings.  

Here I am at 70 years old, and I have CBD.  The bottom line is…CBD never cost me a day of work and I don’t believe that it had any impact on my previous life.  So the question became…do I see an attorney or do I take the settlement money that is offered by the Department of Labor and sign away my future right to sue in the future?

It was a seemingly big, complex decision, but in my mind it became a fairly simple one.  Since I wasn’t willing to take the time it could take for an attorney to “possibly” get me any money or how much would be left after the attorney fee was deducted, I decided to take the government’s offer.  For a government process, it turned out to be fairly easy and relatively painless.  I filed all the paper work, included the medical analysis from National Jewish Health and within two months I received my lump sum stipend.  In addition to the lump sum payment, they pay for 100% of medical treatments, care and associated travel expenses that I incur related to Chronic Beryllium Disease for the rest of my life.  The money was a help, but of course, I would rather have full lung function, especially since I was never a smoker, but...it is what it is.

In my head, I’m singing a couple of lines from the John Mellencamp song, Jack and Diane, “Oh yeah, life goes on.  Long after the thrill of living is gone.”  My life is going on quite well, and damn...I loved that job when I was seventeen.  Sing it with me:  When I was seventeenit was a very good year” – thank you Old Blue Eyes, Frank Sinatra.